of contested cases are dismissed outright — and 43.5% end dismissed or reduced. From 246,349 decided hearings in the city's own records.
Is it worth fighting?
~19% dismiss. Wins: unmarked 'crosswalk' claims at locations without one, vehicle position disputes (bumper overhang vs 'on the crosswalk'), and traffic conditions that forced the position (photograph the gridlock).
What actually wins
No marked crosswalk exists there — photograph the intersection
Vehicle position dispute — photos of actual wheel/bumper position
Forced by traffic/obstruction and vehicle attended
Ticket errors
Evidence to gather
Intersection photos showing markings (or absence)
Vehicle position photos
Traffic context
Fighting it is free. New York lets you dispute online, by mail, or in person — no fee, no lawyer required, decision from a hearing officer. Start at nyc.gov → Dispute a ticket. Check the response deadline printed on your ticket, and answer before it to avoid late penalties.