The commercial-vehicle family: unaltered vehicles with commercial plates, overnight parking on residential streets, platform lifts left lowered.
of the 972,993 drivers who took this exact violation to a hearing had it dismissed outright — they paid nothing at all. Another 31.9% paid less than the ticket said.
The city gives you 30 days from the date on the ticket to ask for a hearing before late penalties start (nyc.gov — Dispute a ticket, checked 2026-09-04). Miss it and you can still be heard, but a judge who finds you guilty will add the penalties. Leave it entirely and the ticket goes into judgment about 100 days after it was issued (same page) — after that the city can collect, and once judgment debt on your plates reaches $350 the vehicle can be booted, then towed if that is unpaid 48 hours later (nyc.gov — Booting and towing, checked 2026-09-04). So tonight is early. You have room.
Of the 80 violation types New York publishes hearing outcomes for, this one is 14th by how often drivers contest it — 972,993 decided hearings. It lands almost exactly on the citywide 26.2% — no easier and no harder than the average ticket.
And look at the second number: 31.9 points of the outcomes are reductions, not dismissals. About 26 in 100 walked out paying nothing — 26.2% — and roughly 32 more paid a smaller amount. On this ticket, "I got somewhere" is more often a cheaper fine than a canceled one — worth knowing before you decide what a hearing is worth to you.
The price moves with the exact code the officer writes: $45–$115.
Look — I'm not going to tell you you'll win. Plenty of people don't, and this page will say so when the city's own file says so. What I can tell you is that on this charge about 26 out of every 100 drivers who bothered to argue it walked away paying nothing, the argument costs you an evening and no money at all, and the city writes down every result whether it likes them or not. Read the numbers, take your photos, and decide with your eyes open. If something here is wrong, email me. One person reads that mail and answers it; expect a reply within a few days.
Not sure this is even the ticket you have?
Put in your plate and state and we'll pull every open violation on it straight from the city's live records — what's owed, how long until each one hits judgment, and the dismissal rate stamped on each ticket. The plate never appears in the address bar and we store none of it.
Look up my plate → · Or check this ticket for a fatal defect →A commercial vehicle ticket in New York City costs between $45 and $115, depending on which code the officer writes and where you were. Source: the New York City Department of Finance fine schedule, violation codes 82, 78, 84 (nyc.gov — parking violation codes and fines), checked 2026-09-02. The amount already includes the $15 New York State Criminal Justice surcharge; late penalties and interest are added on top of it.
These technical tickets are dismissed more often than the citywide average because the definitions are precise and agents apply them loosely. If your vehicle's configuration or the location's status doesn't match the rule's exact words, the ticket fails. It costs you time, not money — the hearing is free — and 26.2% of the 972,993 drivers who took this exact charge to a hearing had it dismissed outright, with 31.9 points more ending in a reduced fine (NYC Open Data hearing dispositions, computed 2026-08-31).
The vehicle doesn't meet the cited rule's definition (alteration status, GVWR, signage) Location not actually residential/restricted as cited. Time window disputes for overnight rules. Ticket errors. Bring: Vehicle configuration photos and registration class, Location zoning/signage photos, The exact rule text vs your facts.
Thirty days from the date on the ticket to request a hearing before late penalties start, and about 100 days from issue before an unanswered ticket goes into judgment (nyc.gov, Dispute a ticket, checked 2026-09-04). Requesting the hearing is free online, on the Pay or Dispute app, or by mail.
Where you were heard matters a little too: across all violation types the boroughs run from 23% to 31.1% dismissed outright. Those are marginals across every charge, not a figure for this one — we hold the city's borough totals and its violation totals, not the cross-tab, and we won't manufacture it. All five boroughs →
Different charge, different odds — none of these is the 26.2% above. Each figure below belongs to the charge it sits on.
Last, and small, and it changes none of the 26.2% above: the builder turns this page plus your own account of the commercial vehicle ticket into a hearing statement. Free to build, free to read, $12.99 for the clean copy. One payment. No subscription. No cut of your fine. Writing it yourself is free and always will be.
← All 80 violation types, with what each one costs
Dismissal rates computed 2026-08-31 from NYC Open Data hearing dispositions. Fine amounts from the NYC Department of Finance schedule, checked 2026-09-02. Deadlines from nyc.gov, Dispute a ticket, checked 2026-09-04. Boot and tow rules from nyc.gov, Booting and towing, checked 2026-09-04. Past outcomes don't guarantee any individual result.
Published · Updated
Thank you. That goes straight to the person who writes these pages.
That didn't send — try once more.